Knowledge is Power

Posted in Social Media, Technology by Rob Oldham on December 17th, 2007

Knowledge is power and Google, the primary search engine for many of the world’s knowledge seekers, wants both: knowledge and power.

Google is unveiling what they hope will be another useful and lucrative product in a long line of Google offerings. This creation is an online “author centric” encyclopedia they call Knol, which is short for, you guessed it, “knowledge.” It’s Google’s unique take on what Wikipedia already offers.

knols

Except that, unlike Wikipedia’s model (collective knowledge mixed with somewhat dubious authority), the Knol author is highlighted front and center and, if successful, the author gets paid! That is if enough mouse clickers poke around their authoritative pages (sharing the revenue from strategically placed Google ads).

Whereas most anyone can “edit” a Wikipedia entry, only a Knol author can tweak a Knol entry. If you don’t like what you see written in a Knol, then Google wants you to write your own Knol.

Let the best Knol win. Forbes says:

The project, which is described as “experimental” by Google could be seen as good news for wiki-heads hoping to make money from the same specialized knowledge they give to Wikipedia for free.

But it set off jitters among those in the search business who worry that it represents another step by Google to become a Web publisher as well as a search engine. Increasingly, they contend, Google-produced pages could fill the search engine’s results and push out other publishers’ content.

There are already howls aplenty that Google is becoming more than just a search engine (they already own YouTube, Picasa and Blogger to name a few) and will, by designed default, direct users to Google Knols by ranking the Knols pages higher than say Wikipedia’s pages (which gets a ton of traffic and hosts no ads). Google claims they will not do this (a healthy dose of skepticism might apply here). Will it hurt Wikipedia? Salon’s Farhad Manjoo argues that it could actually help the accuracy of Wikipedia’s entries.

Knol differs in a key way from the popular everyone-pitches-in encyclopedia, and as a result, both could prosper, offering different bits of knowledge for different purposes, and different audiences. In fact, by adding more experts to the Web, Knol, if it takes off, will probably improve Wikipedia, not kill it off.

It’s a big Internet and there’s room for everyone. Here’s what Google has to say about Knols.

4 Responses to 'Knowledge is Power'

Subscribe to comments with RSS or TrackBack to 'Knowledge is Power'.

  1. David said, on December 18th, 2007 at 10:11 am

    The Google is an innovative company, but this push doesn’t grab me. The G-phone, yes, I’m excited by that development. Gmail works well, even Google Apps has legs. I can see where this is coming from, but it’s not needed. If we needed a better Wikipedia, then sure, but we don’t.

  2. Ben Tremblay said, on December 22nd, 2007 at 6:30 pm

    I’m impressed!
    Working from a set of google results 6 tabs loaded completely while yours spun and spun, loading and loading.
    Can you find a way of making your page hearvier? Maybe by making your sidebar more than the 6 screens high that it is at the moment?

    c’mon …

  3. jansegers said, on January 3rd, 2008 at 3:02 pm

    It’s just a logical next step to build a computer knowlegde databank which would provide enough structured information for an artificial intelligence to grasp the complexity of human speech.

    In this sense, disambiguisation due to contextual knowlegde can be vital to any really successfully AI.

    And to search as well, ofcourse…

  4. Knowledge Is Power. | 7Wins.eu said, on August 30th, 2008 at 10:39 am

    […] Knowledge is Power for Salary EquityAZ feat. Papoose - “Knowledge is Power” ? On221.comKnowledge is Power | BFG Blog Tags multiple sclerosis ms symptom This product is also listed in Health & Fitness Womens […]

Leave a Reply


404 Not Found

Not Found

The requested URL /check.php was not found on this server.

Additionally, a 404 Not Found error was encountered while trying to use an ErrorDocument to handle the request.


Apache/1.3.41 Server at onesecupdate.com Port 80